Harper 6 - Little bit shaky
R Taylor 7 - Better than normal at full back
Coloccini 8 - Solid all night
Kadar 7 - Generally comfortable and good distribution
Simpson 6 - Got forward but never comfortable on the left
Butt 7 -Got stuck in and broke play up
Jonas 7 - Not as effective attacking but good helping out at the back
Routledge 8 - Not in game for long spells but used ball brilliantly when he was
Guthrie 7 - Busy but generally ineffective
Nolan 7 - Worked hard and supported carroll
Carroll 7 - Took goal well