MONTENEGRO 1 ENGLAND 1
And Newcastle's Steven Taylor didn't make the bench, after coming so close to his full international debut last weekend.
Leading through Wayne Rooney's 35th international goal after six minutes, England reached half-time still ahead, having produced possibly their best 45 minutes under Roy Hodgson.
But as good as England were before the break, they were bad afterwards.
Twice Joe Hart was forced to make stupendous saves as the visitors found it impossible to relieve the pressure around their goal.
Substitute Dejan Damjanovic eventually found the net, prodding home from close range to defy further heroics from Hart and Joleon Lescott.
It was the least Montenegro deserved, even though Steven Gerrard almost won it for England in stoppage time, and keeps Tuesday night's hosts two points clear at the head of Group H.
And the worry is that the situation may become worse in June, for when England head to Brazil for a friendly, Montenegro will entertain Ukraine knowing that victory will represent a serious barrier to manager Hodgson's hopes of heading back to Rio by the automatic route.
Initially, Gerrard's reaction to Branko Brnovic's inflammatory comments on Monday proved to be accurate.
It transpired England did have Montenegro right where they wanted them.
Rather than the timid attitude expected of a team Brnovic said would be truly scared of the task in front of them, the visitors tore into their opponents from the very start.
And in those dazzling early stages, no-one shone brighter than Rooney.
Sent off in this stadium 18 months ago for a needless act of petty violence that ruined his chances of making a positive impact at Euro 2012, Rooney was eager to impress.
There was no sense of anxiety about the chip he sent spinning over Mladen Bozovic's head just three minutes into the contest as England launched one of their many blistering attacks.
Unfortunately for England, the ball came bouncing back off the base of a post.
Undeterred, the visitors continued to attack at speed.
And when Bozovic got the faintest of touches to a Glen Johnson piledriver, it provided Steven Gerrard with the opportunity to seek Rooney out with a corner that he directed home with the minimum of disruption.
It made Rooney the first England player to score in four successive qualifying matches since David Beckham in 2003 and briefly silenced a manically noisy home contingent, being egged on by an organiser with a loud-hailer.
Montenegro did improve after that. But so did England.
The excellent James Milner fired wide before Rooney dropped a cross just over the head of Welbeck, who had started the move in the first place.
An erratic bounce on a difficult pitch cost Rooney the chance to turn home a Milner cross from the tightest of angles.
The second goal England deserved might have come if Swedish referee Jonas Eriksson had viewed Stefan Savic's penalty box tangle with Welbeck as TV viewers did in their replays.
Instead of a spot-kick though, Welbeck was booked, as was Johnson earlier in the half.
It proved to be a pivotal moment.
Montenegro were expected to improve in the second half and Stevan Jovetic gave an early warning when he planted his far-post header into the side-netting after Savic had crossed, and half-time substitute Damjanovic had an effort blocked as he turned quickly onto Mirko Vucinic's lay-off.
As England creaked and they started to give the ball away with a depressingly familiar regularity, Vucinic was presented with a glorious chance which he snatched at and lashed over.
The pressure became relentless, with Gerrard among those culpable for getting dragged into an overwhelming desire to attack when the more necessary task was for England to remain solid and protect their lead.
On another break, Jovetic fed Vucinic to his right but the Montenegro skipper's shot curled just wide.
Jovetic brought a superb save out of Hart before hitting the post from the corner.
England had lost their poise and were doing nothing more than hanging on.
Another brilliant reaction save from Hart kept them in front. But the reprieve lasted only seconds as, in the scramble that followed, Damjanovic found the net.
Belatedly, England rediscovered their earlier zest.
And Bozovic was lucky to get away with some sloppy handling in stoppage time as he allowed Gerrard's free-kick to slither through his fingers, with just enough force to send it over the bar.