Formerly the club's undisputed No.1, Given's only two appearances for The Magpies this season have come in the Carling Cup. Given Or Harper? Who Would YOU Pick?
Formerly the club's undisputed No.1, Given's only two appearances for The Magpies this season have come in the Carling Cup. An injury to the Republic of Ireland international initially gave the gloves to Steve Harper, who has retained his place for Premier League games.
Allardyce draws comfort from having two quality keepers to select from, but accepts Given may be frustrated with the current situation.
Personally I'd go for Given, but I am not Newcastle manager. And I still feel Harper won't be in his current position for long. But what do YOU think? Please put your comments on the message board.
Allardyce: "I chose Shay on Tuesday, but in reverse I would have picked Steven Harper for the Arsenal game if Shay had been playing regularly in the Premiership.
"When you have got two outstanding goalkeepers the hardest part of the job is keeping one happy when one is not playing and the other one is in the team.
"That is the hardest part of management, but to have two such outstanding keepers is also comforting.
"Will Shay be happy on the bench? He cannot be. Impossible. Steve Harper is slightly better at it, but it is not about making a decision based on who will create more problems for me.
"It is all about what you think is the right thing, or the right goalkeeper, for that particular time."