In the end, the Chelsea goalkeeper saved three penalties and got his hand to the other three.
Meanwhile ... in Kiev Joe Hart never got a sniff of any of Italy's penalties ... and England coach Roy Hodgson said on the day of the match: "I have not given penalties a thought; that is a defeatist attitude."
Well, I would rather say it was a NECESSITY. Both teams were even on the betting and it was always going to be a tight game, so why on earth did he disregard the inevitable?
But today he believes his players can hold their heads high.
Roy Hodgson: "I thought the chances were there for both teams.
"I actually thought we created some very good chances ourselves.
"But as the half wore on, and extra-time, I thought we were tiring badly and we weren't able to establish enough good possession in the midfield so they came at us time and time again.
"In some ways, you might have even preferred it if they'd have got a goal in that time when they were playing well as that's a little bit less of a cruel way to lose than on penalties.
"We've gone out but we've gone out without actually losing the game and I think we've gone out with our heads held high.
"I personally think the lads have done a fantastic job for their country and I also think that people have appreciated it.
"I really can't fault the players for their effort. Towards the end we had a lot of players out there running on empty really.
"Tired legs, fighting off cramp - but they kept going right to the end.
"But when you go to penalties you have a chance. Unfortunately it was Italy who took that chance and not us.
"The five penalty takers we have are good ones and we've been doing a fair amount in training with Ashley Young smashing in penalties on a regular basis so of course you hope.
"I know everyone in this country has an obsession with penalties and that's going to get even worse now but the fact is you can't reproduce the tired legs.
"You can't reproduce the pressure. You can't reproduce the feeling of nervous tension. They stood up to it better than we did, (Andrea) Pirlo's penalty being a classic example.
"Pirlo was very good wasn't he? I've worked with him in the past and I know what a very good player he is. He seemed to always find time and room and very rarely wasted a pass.
"We worked hard to keep him in check but obviously a player of that quality you can only keep in check to a certain extent. He will find a way of getting the ball even though you get people around him.
"If this group of players continue to show the same degree of determination and will to be a team and work so hard as a team we've got quality players who can come into the squad who will add to the competition.
"So I'm convinced it won't be that long before we beat a top nation. We had our chance today. We came close to taking it but not quite.
"But I think we've got to keep building on the work we've done at this tournament and make sure that the good things that we've done remain and work on some of the things we could've done a little bit better."